Housing market · October 2026 data

St. Marys, PA Housing Market

Cold Market

Metro-level monthly sale metrics for rental investors — prices, inventory, pace, and negotiation signals. Figures represent the St. Marys, PA metro area.

Median sale price

$416,037

156.1% YoY

Days on market

69 days

2.8% YoY

Homes for sale

50

56.3% YoY

3-bed rent ÷ price

0.32%

HUD rent ÷ median price

Renting in St. Marys, PA

HUD Fair Market Rent, FY 2027

Studio$749
1 bed$879
2 bed$1,014
3 bed$1,328
4 bed$1,333

Elk County, PA. HUD sets these at the 40th percentile of rents, including utilities, across the whole area, so a single home can rent for more or less. The 2-bedroom figure is up 4.2% from last year's.

Rent against the median price

Median sale price (October 2026)
$416,037
HUD 3-bedroom rent
$1,328/mo
Rent ÷ price
0.32%

Many investors use 1% as a first screen. At the median price that would take $4,160 a month in rent. It is a screen, not an answer: taxes, insurance and the loan decide whether a home cash flows.

Run these numbers in the calculator

Starts with the median price and HUD 3-bedroom rent. Swap in a real listing's numbers. Start blank instead

Free monthly update

Get St. Marys, PA's numbers each month

One email when new figures come out: the median price, how fast homes are selling, HUD’s rent for the area and the rent-to-price ratio.

Free. We'll email a link to confirm first. Used only for these updates, with a one-click unsubscribe. See an example · Privacy policy

St. Marys, PA market read

What this month's sale figures say about prices, pace and how much room buyers have.

Cold Market

Inventory is high and homes are sitting longer — a buyer's market.

St. Marys, PA market summary

The St. Marys, PA metro area housing market is cooling down. As of October 2026, the median home sale price is $416K, up 156.1% year-over-year. Homes are spending a median of 69 days on the market, 2.8% shorter than a year ago.

There are 50 homes for sale — 56.3% more than last year. With 24.7 months of supply, this is a buyer's market. 7 new listings were added during this period, down 22.2% year-over-year.

Homes are selling for 85.2% of their list price on average, suggesting room for negotiation. 0.0% of homes sell above their asking price. 31.9% of listings have had a price drop.

Investor takeaway

The cooling market may present buying opportunities with less competition and more negotiating leverage. High inventory relative to sales pace means buyers have options and sellers may be flexible on price. A significant share of sellers are cutting prices, which can signal motivated sellers and potential deals.

Rental Investor Snapshot

Labels below come from monthly sale-market indicators only. True cash flow requires local rent, taxes, insurance, vacancy, and expense assumptions — model those in the rental calculator, then sanity-check against sale-speed signals here.

Market temperature
Cooling
Buyer leverage
High
Pricing signal vs. U.S. median
Near U.S. median (price only)
Investor fit (heuristic)
Negotiation · BRRRR

Watch-outs

  • Slower sales (longer days on market) can mean more time to diligence — but also weaker demand.
  • Elevated price cuts can signal negotiation room — verify condition, rents, and comps street-by-street.
  • Higher months of supply usually improves buyer leverage on price and terms.

Suggested next step: Run a rental property analysis with your own rent, financing, vacancy, and expense assumptions — then sanity-check against this market's sale-speed and negotiation signals.

Market Opportunity Score

Based on current market conditions

93

Contributing Factors

Months of Supply↑ 24.7
Days on Market↑ 69
Price Drops↑ 31.9%
Sale-to-List Ratio↑ 85.2%
Market Temperature↑ Cold

How This Market Compares

vs. National Median

Median Price (National: $389K)↑ 7.1%
Days on Market (National: 50)↑ 38.0%
Inventory (National: 1,233,178)↓ 100.0%

vs. Pennsylvania Median

Median Price (Pennsylvania: $309K)↑ 34.4%
Days on Market (Pennsylvania: 36)↑ 91.7%

Detailed market metrics

Price

What homes are selling for

Median sale price
$416K156.1% YoY
Median list price
$192K
Price per sq ft
$261
Sale-to-list ratio
85.2%
Sold above list
0.0%
Listings with a price drop
31.9%

Supply

How much is for sale

Active inventory
5056.3% YoY
Months of supply
24.7
New listings
722.2% YoY

Pace

How fast homes are moving

Median days on market
69 days2.8% YoY
Homes sold
266.7% YoY
Pending sales
12
Off market in 2 weeks
24.4%

All figures are for October 2026, from Redfin. Year-over-year changes compare with the same month a year earlier.

St. Marys, PA housing market FAQs

What is the median home price in St. Marys, PA?

For the latest published month, the median sale price in St. Marys, PA is $416,037. Median means half of homes sold above that price and half below — it is a useful benchmark, not a rule for every listing.

What is the fair market rent in St. Marys, PA?

HUD's FY 2027 Fair Market Rent for the Elk County, PA is $1,014 a month for a 2-bedroom and $1,328 for a 3-bedroom ($749 for a studio, $1,333 for 4 bedrooms). HUD sets Fair Market Rents at the 40th percentile of rents across the whole area, including utilities, so a specific home can rent for more or less.

What is the rent-to-price ratio in St. Marys, PA?

Using Redfin's median sale price of $416,037 for October 2026 and HUD's 3-bedroom Fair Market Rent of $1,328, a month's rent is 0.32% of the price in St. Marys, PA. Many investors use about 1% as a first screen, which at this median price would take $4,160 a month. It is a screen, not a verdict: property taxes, insurance and financing decide whether a specific home cash flows.

Is St. Marys, PA a buyer's or seller's market?

With about 24.7 months of supply, conditions often favor buyers (inventory is relatively high versus sales pace). That can mean more time to negotiate and compare listings.

How long do homes stay on the market in St. Marys, PA?

For the latest published month, the median days on market in St. Marys, PA is 69 days — half of homes went pending faster and half slower.

Is St. Marys, PA good for rental property investors?

Sale-market stats show how competitive buying is (speed, negotiation, inventory). They do not prove rent performance. St. Marys, PA can still work for rentals if the numbers work on a deal-by-deal basis — use local rent comps, financing, vacancy, and expenses in the rental property calculator.

How should investors analyze a rental property in St. Marys, PA?

Start with purchase price, financing, rent, vacancy, operating expenses, and capital repairs. Stress-test rates and rent. Will It Flow’s rental property calculator is built to translate those inputs into cash flow, DSCR, cap rate, and cash-on-cash return for St. Marys, PA deals.

Compare more Pennsylvania metro markets

Explore nearby sale-market pace and pricing, then run a shortlist through the rental property calculator.

All Pennsylvania metros →

Keep exploring

Step up to national trends, or compare St. Marys, PA with other metros.

Pair this view with the rental property calculator, DSCR calculator, and cap rate calculator — or browse all calculators.

Underwrite a rental in St. Marys, PA with real numbers

Use Will It Flow for cash flow, DSCR, cap rate, and cash-on-cash return — free and fast.

Housing market data provided by Redfin, a national real estate brokerage. Not financial advice. Always consult a qualified professional before making investment decisions.